web stats

Summer Recipe – Oreo Pudding Pops!

Oreo Pudding Pops

Hi Tatertots & Jello friends! It’s Melissa from No. 2 Pencil, and today I’m sharing a fun summer time treat, Oreo Pudding Pops! These are so easy to make, and I know you are going to love them. They taste just like the original Jell-O pudding pops.

Melissa Profile

A few weeks ago, I shared a fun patriotic version of pudding pops. Well, when I found a box of Oreo Jell-O pudding at my local grocery store, I knew I needed to make a cookies ‘n creme version.


Oreo Pudding Pops


These pudding pops are so creamy and delicious. They have bits of cookies and creme throughout, and they have a whole Oreo cookie inside!

Oreo Pudding Pops

Oreo Pudding Pops

makes 5 pudding pops – double or triple recipe as needed


1 4.2 oz box of Oreo Cookies ‘n Creme Instant Jell-O pudding

1 1/2 cups of milk

5 Oreo cookies


Stir together pudding mix and milk.

Transfer pudding to a large plastic baggie and snip off a corner.

Squeeze pudding into popsicle mold from baggie.

Tap popsicle mold onto counter top to even out pudding mixture and get rid of air bubbles.

Divide Oreo cookies and use just the cookie half with the creme. Note: A whole cookie will not fit in my popsicle mold once the stick is inserted.

Slide cookie chocolate side out against side of popsicle mold.

Insert popsicle sticks and freeze for 2-3 hours, or overnight.



Enjoy your Oreo Pudding Pops!


Oreo Pudding Pops



Thank you for having me again, Jen! I just love sharing with Tatertots and Jello readers!




Melissa – those Oreo Pops look amazing!! 

I can’t wait to make some!!

Here are some other awesome ideas from No. 2 Pencil

strawberry tart

This Strawberry Cobbler would be perfect to make for the Fourth – and it’s Melissa’s Grandmother’s recipe!

jello pudding pops

Another great idea tomake for the Fourth – Jello Pudding Pops

uncle sam mustache pops

And how cute are these Uncle Sam Mustache Pops?

Be sure to head over to No. 2 Pencil for more awesome ideas and recipes! 

Have a Beautiful Day! 


jen signature


  1. Made these for the kids today! Thanks for sharing the idea!

  2. The oreo pops look great, definitely going to make this for our after dinner dessert. Thanks!

  3. Hi, I love this idea especially for my picky eater. May you share what popsicle molds you use to make the pops.


  4. Love this! I’ll be making some tonight!

  5. YUM!!! my kids would love this=-especially that giant oreo in the middle!

  6. Why didn’t I think of this myself? GENIUS! Thanks for sharing :)

    Dana Ivy
    http://www.iadorewhatilove.com – check,out my blog!

  7. OH my- these are all so yummy. Guess I’m just going to have to make them all :)
    Gina recently posted…American Flag Printable

  8. These look so delicious! I just shared an Oreo recipe on my blog, too! Check it out! http://domesticsuperhero.com/2013/06/12/cookies-and-cream-cheesecake-cupcakes/

  9. Thank you, Jen! I love sharing on TT&J!

  10. Wow – I can’t wait to cool down with these!

  11. I am so doing this. My fav Blizzard from Dairy Queen is the Oreo one and my kids can’t stop eating the cookies. Thanks for sharing!
    Alex @ northstory recently posted…Father’s Day Cards


  1. […] Oreo Pudding Pops by Tatertots and Jello […]

  2. […] Oreo Pudding Pops from Tatertots and Jello […]

  3. […] Insert popsicle sticks and freeze for 2-3 hours, or overnight. Read more at http://tatertotsandjello.com/2013/06/summer-recipe-oreo-pudding-pops.html#GYJMurjYse8rh3yt.99 […]

  4. […] Did someone say Oreo Pudding Pops? […]

  5. […] Oreo Pudding Jumps (Tatertots and Jello) […]

  6. […] freeze: Strawberry Cheesecake Popsicles. I recently made the Oreo Pudding Pops I featured a few weeks ago on Friday Favorites, and they were AMAZING. I am loving this creamy […]

  7. […] lick: Oreo Pudding Pops. I finally got my popsicle molds (snagged some from my Mom who bought, like, 10 sets of 5 for the […]

  8. […] Recipe: Oreo Pudding Pops […]

  9. […] up I think I need to try some pudding popsicles.    How fun do these homemade Oreo Pudding Pops by No. 2 Pencil over at Tatertots and Jello look?   So […]

  10. […] Oreo Pudding Pops found on Tatertots and Jello. 2. Oreo Icebox Cake found on Cookies and Cups. 3. Dirt Pudding Cups found on Oh […]

  11. […] Favorite Treat: Oreo Pudding Pops […]

  12. […] lick: Oreo Pudding Pops. The love child of my favorite ice cream, Cookies ‘n’ Cream. and my favorite childhood […]