Tatertots and Jello

COLORFUL HAPPY HOME -- Daily DIY, Decor, Craft and Recipe Tutorial

  • My Home
    • 1905 Cottage
    • Daybreak House
  • DIY
    • DIY Projects and Ideas
    • Organizing
    • Tutorials
    • Printables
  • Decor
    • Spring Projects
    • Summer Projects
    • Fall Projects
  • Crafts
    • Kids Crafts
    • Painting Projects
    • Paper Projects
    • Sewing
    • Wreaths
  • Holidays
    • Valentines Day
    • Easter
    • Halloween
    • Thanksgiving
    • Christmas
    • HAPPY Holidays Series!
  • Recipes

Explore

  • my home
  • diy
  • decor
  • crafts
  • holiday
  • printables
  • recipes

Connect

Home » diy » Washing Clothes with Baking Soda vs. Tide: I Tried Them Both and This is What Happened!

diy · March 2, 2018

Washing Clothes with Baking Soda vs. Tide: I Tried Them Both and This is What Happened!

Tatertots & Jello is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.

In partnership with Tide

tide versus natural hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened.tide versus laundry tricks - I tried them and this is what happened!

You know I love trying and sharing hacks on my blog. And one area I haven’t done yet is “Laundry Hacks”. There are so many myths and misconceptions all across the web, about adding household items to a bargain detergent to get amazing results. But where did this start? For me, it started with my mom who always gave me ridiculous tips and tricks for getting my clothes smelling better and looking brighter. Now I hate not to do what my mother tells me, but I don’t just take anyone’s word for it – so I HAD to test and see, do any of her hacks with bargain detergents actually work against my favorite laundry detergent, Tide? Spoiler alert – they didn’t but keep reading to find out why!

 

For my test, I held a taco night with my family and had everyone wear bright white aprons so we could get them as messy as possible. We got COVERED in stains!

Now that I had all the taco stains I needed, it was time to go where the experts are, and what better place than the Tide Lab in Cincinnati. It is the best place in the world to test which hack made the biggest difference. There were SO many different kinds of washers there. They test their products on EVERY kind of washing machine on the market – energy-efficient models, old models, models you can only find in different countries. I also found out that there are over 200 scientists who work for Tide, developing the BEST products that really work.

tide versus natural hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened.

Moms and Bloggers – we were excited to try laundry hacks!

My mom had always told me that using baking soda in laundry with bargain detergent was a sure-fire way to get stains out so I couldn’t wait to put it to the test. When I got to the Tide Lab I washed TWO aprons – one with a baking soda paste (that we applied ourselves) and bargain detergent and the other with the new Tide Ultra Oxi Liquid. Not only was the baking soda paste messy, but it requires pre-treating clothing before washing for hours. Who has time for that?

tide versus natural hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened.

tide versus natural hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened.

Tide Ultra Oxi is one of Tide’s newest products. It’s Tide’s first detergent combination that gives consumers the benefit of tough stain fighting with built-in pre-treaters (so no waiting for pre-treatment, unlike baking soda). Although we used the liquid formula at the labs, they also have it available in PODS (which we love!!!). It truly beats laundry hacks – in fact one dose of Tide Ultra Oxi removes stains better than FOUR doses of bargain detergent and an ENTIRE box of baking soda.

Tide versus cleaning hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened

We also learned about Tide Fresh Coral Blast, which has been developed to work with today’s modern synthetic fabrics that tend to hold in odors and stains more than natural cottons (who knew??). I found out at the Tide Lab that Tide Fresh Coral Blast has special technology that releases scents the more you move. It’s amazing.

Tide versus cleaning hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened

tide versus natural hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened.

While at the lab, we bloggers played scientist for the day and did some experiments. We tested out vinegar, lemon juice and baking soda with bargain detergents. For one experiment, we squeezed a WHOLE bag of lemons to see if lemon juice would get clothes brighter than Tide. No surprise here – it does not and it also took a ton of time, which I would not have the patience for at home.

Tide versus cleaning hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened

 

tide versus laundry tricks - I tried them all and this is what happened.

(here we are in the labs – with our aprons PRIOR to cleaning)

 

At the end of the day, we had our grand reveal with our taco night aprons. What do you think happened when we got our aprons back from the cleaning lab?? Here are the results!

 

 

To recap, we washed TWO aprons – one with a baking soda paste (that we applied ourselves) + bargain detergent and the other with the new Tide Ultra Oxi liquid. You can see in the pictures that washing with baking soda still left stains on the apron, while the other apron washed with Tide Ultra Oxi liquid is white (not to mention that it took much less time to clean). And these were badly stained. I was SUPER impressed.

Tide versus cleaning hacks - I tried them both and this is what happened

tide versus natural laundry tricks - this is what happened

Tide versus bargain detergents and baking soda - this is what happened

 

 

 

So here’s the challenge – try TIDE Ultra Oxi and compare it with YOUR detergent. Share the results!

Let me know what you think!! 

xoxo

Kansas City Steaks

 

 

Posted By: Jen · In: diy

How to Make Musical Note Party Cookies!
Best Friday Features — and $50 Savers Gift Card Giveaway!

You’ll Also Love

Tatertots and Jello Annual Declutter and Cleaning Challenge
Effortless Window Cleaning: DIY Natural Solution and Telescoping System
5 Laundry Tips for Small Laundry Rooms and a Free Laundry Schedule Printable! Laundry hacks to help you save time.5 Laundry Tips for Small Laundry Rooms and a Free Laundry Schedule Printable!

Comments

  1. Scarlett Smith says

    August 19, 2019 at 1:44 PM

    How can I contact P&G directly? I have used Tide for many years (I’m old) and have always loved it. In the last couple of months, I have bought three different jugs (largest size) of Tide and the smell is AWFUL. I cannot tolerate it. I looked at the P&G website to contact them directly but you can’t, unless you’re a retailer or are applying for a “position” in their company. I had coupons off for more and foolishly bought the two additional jugs. Smells awful. Clothes have to be washed in another laundry detergent to get rid of the smell! I have switched to Gain—for right now, anyway. I don’t know why they’ve messed with the original formula, but they have. Or, the factories they are allowing to manufacture the Tide have messed up big time! It just really STINKS. Can you give me an address to contact them? Thanks!

    • Jen says

      August 19, 2019 at 9:07 PM

      Hi Scarlett!

      That’s so weird! There are other scents of Tide that you an buy now. Have you tried any of those? I don’t have the direct email to anyone at Tide. It was a PR company that arranged our trip there. Do you have Instagram? You can DM their social media person on Instagram and they are really good about responding. I bet they would have some answers for you!

      xoxo

      • Scarlett says

        August 26, 2019 at 7:25 PM

        Thanks, Jen
        I really have not tried the other scents; I never really cared for them. I like the original and want to stay with it. I did talk with a salesperson at Walmart and we opened a bottle that said “unscented” but both agreed it DID have a scent.
        Like I said, I’m old, so I never got into instagram and facebook. Guess I’m just stuck with two awful-smelling jugs of Tide.
        Thanks for responding!
        Blessings!

  2. Christy says

    June 9, 2019 at 9:52 AM

    So do you all get free supplies or are you paid by Proctor and Gamble?

  3. Diane says

    March 2, 2018 at 11:41 AM

    Did you know that Tide has a “D” rating as far as carcinogenics are concerned. Look it up in the Environmental Working Group (EWG) website. It will give you all the info you need.

    • Jen says

      March 2, 2018 at 12:31 PM

      That’s interesting! I will look it up. Thanks Diane!

      xoxo

  4. Andrea says

    March 2, 2018 at 7:06 AM

    I think this is a nice advertisement for tide.

    • Jen says

      March 2, 2018 at 10:02 AM

      haha! Actually I found out a lot of information I didn’t know before. It was really interesting!

      xoxo

Hi! I'm Jen Hadfield. I'm a mom of 5 restoring an 1891 home in the heart of Salt Lake City. I love being creative and sharing simple ideas to make your life easier and more beautiful!

Receive the Latest Crafts, DIY, Recipes and More in your INBOX!

Follow us on Pinterest! It's awesome!

Top Posts & Pages

Copycat Panera Spinach and Artichoke Egg Soufflés - SO good!
Spruce up Your Outdoor Space with a DIY Recirculating Fountain! (tutorial)
12 Must-Have Items to Pack on an Alaskan Cruise!
A New Deck in Under 30 Minutes!
DIY Fountains to Make Your Yard Amazing!
DIY Secret: How to Print on Post-It Notes (and Free Printable Template)

 

Popular Posts

  • Copycat Panera Spinach and Artichoke Egg Soufflés - SO good!
    Copycat Panera Spinach and Artichoke Egg Soufflés - SO good!
  • Spruce up Your Outdoor Space with a DIY Recirculating Fountain! (tutorial)
    Spruce up Your Outdoor Space with a DIY Recirculating Fountain! (tutorial)
  • 12 Must-Have Items to Pack on an Alaskan Cruise!
    12 Must-Have Items to Pack on an Alaskan Cruise!
  • A New Deck in Under 30 Minutes!
    A New Deck in Under 30 Minutes!
  • DIY Fountains to Make Your Yard Amazing!
    DIY Fountains to Make Your Yard Amazing!
  • DIY Secret: How to Print on Post-It Notes (and Free Printable Template)
    DIY Secret: How to Print on Post-It Notes (and Free Printable Template)
  • How to Change a Recessed Can Light into a Pendant Light with No Remodeling!
    How to Change a Recessed Can Light into a Pendant Light with No Remodeling!

As seen in





Amazon Affiliate

Tatertots & Jello is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to amazon.com.
  • About Me
  • Advertising
  • Get Featured

Copyright © 2025 Tatertots and Jello · Privacy
This site is a place for positive discussion and ideas. Negative talk, comments that disparage others, and similar are not welcome and may be removed.